PapersWithELO
← ICLR 2024 leaderboard

On Learning with a Concurrent Verifier: Convexity, Improving Bounds, and Complex Requirements

Masaaki Nishino, Kengo Nakamura, Norihito Yasuda

learning theoryGeneralization analysisverifier
37.50100
Fused
band ≈ ±13 pct pts (from σ = 0.27)
28.40100
Mimo
band ≈ ±18 pct pts (from σ = 0.35)
51.70100
DeepSeek
band ≈ ±20 pct pts (from σ = 0.41)

OpenReview ground truth

Rejected

Abstract

Machine learning technologies have been used in a wide range of practical applications. In them, it is preferable to guarantee that the input-output pairs of a model satisfy the given requirements. The recently proposed concurrent verifier (CV) is a module combined with machine learning models to guarantee that the model's input-output pairs satisfy the given requirements. The previous paper provides a generalization analysis of learning with a CV to show how the model's learnability changes using a CV. Although the paper provides basic learnability results, many CV properties remain unrevealed. Moreover, the previous work assumed a CV always works correctly, and requirements are imposed on a single input-output pair, which limits the situation where we can use a CV. We show the learning algorithms that preserve convexity when using a CV. We also show conditions that using a CV improves the generalization error bound. Moreover, we analyze the learnability when a CV is incorrect, or requirements are imposed on the combination of multiple input-output pairs.

Author context

Most prolific author: 1 submissions (credibility 1.00).

No mass-submission penalty for this paper (authors within normal submission volume).

Aggregate statistics only — no individual author rankings.

Ranking trajectory

Percentile by tournament round — convergence indicates rating stability.

Battle history — 42 comparisons

Ranked above opponent in 49% of matchups.

Judge assessments

Mean overall score 0.0 ± 0.0 (n = 42)